What's new

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
This is such a treat - always a pleasure to see the work of a master, so many sweet little touches in there. I particularly like that you moved the edges of the ground plane in from the edge of the board. If the solder mask rubbed through against the edge of the guide there won't be conductivity. I'm sure there are a million more that I haven't found yet
I've probably done something like this:

View: https://youtu.be/ahKH19iN2SM


I like and hate routing PCBs in equal measure. It's a perverse logic puzzle trying to route everything without resorting to hopping back and forth between both sides of the PCB. I am an amateur though so I've probably committed some sort of routing faux pas somewhere though...

My cards have been swapped over a few times and I noticed that the little threaded tabs in the PVM chassis that hold the card secure had a tendency to catch and scratch the solder mask off the PCB so I just added a no-fill zone on the top and bottom edges which should hopefully fix that. Although with any luck I shouldn't need to swap cards so often, if at all!

The only other significant change I made is to move the two switches back from the edge of the card slightly. I noticed with a cap fitted to the switch you can still see exposed plunger/spring between the cap and the bracket so I just moved the switches inboard by a few mm so the base of the cap will sit inside the bracket. It will probably mean the bracket will need the holes around the switches made slightly bigger and standardise on either round or square caps. 1RBLK is the part # for a black round cap I was leaning towards using, they're 5mm in diameter.
 

hatmoose

Champion
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Messages
924
Reaction score
1,941
Location
New Zealand
Boards on order now (along with neobiosmasta, blueSCSI, SAT2Neo, a 42 pin adapter for the 866, and some others that I've forgotten already.
Now I have 20 working days to wait for delivery and to reflect on the significant natural beauty of living in the middle of nowhere.
 

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
I've got my PCBs now. I'm just waiting for the components to arrive. When I built the original clones my component order was getting messed about with line items disappearing from stock, and every time I amended it a) it took 2/3 days and then b) something else would disappear from stock. So I placed another order with everything definitely in stock with the aim to cancel the original order. Except I forgot to, so it's been in pending since August last year, literally now just waiting for those pesky ADG1611 ICs to finish being produced. I worked out what additional components I need to complete the BoM for the new design and ordered those separately so I'm just waiting for this order to ship.

For the standoffs, I've now tried both 23 & 24 mm; 23 mm seem to be a better fit IMHO.

The only revision I might make to the PCBs are the cutouts for the two securing tabs on the SCART connector. When I ordered the original clone boards, JLCPCB cut them as square holes, but on this batch they're just circular and the tabs won't go through easily. I'll try and square the holes with a rasp this time, and I'll fix up the SCART footprint so its less ambiguous.
 

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
Still waiting for components to arrive so I’ve had a go at designing a suitable bracket in OpenSCAD. Printed the first couple of mm to check all of the cutouts are in the right place and it’s mostly there:

CA017FE7-2903-489F-830D-180938EF97C2.jpeg

Not bad for my first attempt! I’ve got a couple of sub-mm tweaks to make; BNC cutouts could be a tiny bit smaller and I didn’t quite get the angle right on the SCART socket but that was mostly by eye as every technical drawing out there omits that measurement.

I added some labels to each port and they’re readable, but a bit blobby around the edges, I’m not sure if I can tweak some settings or need a finer nozzle for that level of detail? I’ve literally just stuck with printer/slicer defaults so far.
 

hatmoose

Champion
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Messages
924
Reaction score
1,941
Location
New Zealand
looking awesome! And great work in OpenSCAD there. I’m trying to transition my entire tool chain away from rental software and onto FOSS too.
FreeCAD (hard!)
KiCAD (awesome!)
Slic3r (an oldie but a goodie)
My Ender3 pro is about the cheapest 3D printer on the market, it can achieve good results with some tuning of the settings. From that photo it looks like your flow rate is a bit low, I followed YouTube vids for how to dial it in.

The boards have arrived, my wife will be giving them to me for Christmas. Can’t wait for Christmas Day!
 

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
looking awesome! And great work in OpenSCAD there. I’m trying to transition my entire tool chain away from rental software and onto FOSS too.
FreeCAD (hard!)
I used FreeCAD to create some 3D models, ironically for a KiCAD library for some JST connectors, and I found the UI a bit confusing but eventually managed to create what I needed. I was going to use FreeCAD again to design this bracket and found myself getting frustrated in the UI looking for the tools/options I knew existed, so I thought I'd stop and give OpenSCAD a go instead. I quite like that it's basically a reproducible script.

I like CAD in general and did some AutoCAD qualifications about 25 years ago on what is now an ancient DOS version so I think my brain works quite well in "CAD mode".
KiCAD (awesome!)
I've only ever used Eagle previously and then jumped to KiCAD when AutoDesk borged it and started charging a subscription.
From that photo it looks like your flow rate is a bit low, I followed YouTube vids for how to dial it in.
It's either that or the infill overlap I think, I'll fiddle with the settings for the next test print once I've adjusted all of the ports.
 

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
After a couple more partial prints I got all the ports in the right place so I thought what the heck, print the whole thing out in its intended black filament:

6F5E158F-86C9-4EEA-92D1-BE12DF756EF5.jpeg


I then test fitted everything together with some of the various ports in situ (they’ll be the last things I solder in normally):

88D4A6D9-7686-4057-9CB8-1E21946F3354.jpeg


I’m pretty happy with that.

While I’m still waiting for components I’ll get on with starting to make the changes to the Arduino firmware.
 

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
I've literally just approved Mouser to ship my component order, minus some ceramic caps that appear to be unobtanium but I can manage without.
 

hatmoose

Champion
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Messages
924
Reaction score
1,941
Location
New Zealand
I've literally just approved Mouser to ship my component order, minus some ceramic caps that appear to be unobtanium but I can manage without.
Got distracted, back into it now

Just looking at the BOM, perfection does not come cheap...
U3 = ADG733BRUZ
U4 = ISL59885ISZ
U6 = ISL4089IBZ - this one in particular is a spicy meatball :)

Were you able to find a cheaper supplier than Digikey/mouser?
 

hatmoose

Champion
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Messages
924
Reaction score
1,941
Location
New Zealand
Started soldering it all together today.

The ISL4089IBZ is about a $30 part, came in its own bag, in its own box, with clear instructions to place on a flat surface before opening the box - and inside this tiny little chip. Fun!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3927.jpeg
    IMG_3927.jpeg
    102.7 KB · Views: 21
  • IMG_3926.jpeg
    IMG_3926.jpeg
    132.5 KB · Views: 20

hatmoose

Champion
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Messages
924
Reaction score
1,941
Location
New Zealand
Getting close now - If I make another one of these I'll probably shuffle the bottom 5-pin JST connector back 1/4 an inch. The big array of caps makes it a tight fit at the moment.

I do absolutely love JST-NH; The connectors are nice, the pins are thick, sockets always crimp really nicely, the mechanical strain relief is awesome - what a great system.
IMG_3948.jpegIMG_3947.jpegIMG_3946.jpeg
 

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
Got distracted, back into it now

Just looking at the BOM, perfection does not come cheap...
U3 = ADG733BRUZ
U4 = ISL59885ISZ
U6 = ISL4089IBZ - this one in particular is a spicy meatball :)

Were you able to find a cheaper supplier than Digikey/mouser?
I think I found a handful of ISL59885ISZ on eBay, and the ISL4089IBZ was available from RS.
 

bodgit

Professional
Joined
Sep 6, 2020
Messages
233
Reaction score
417
Location
UK
Getting close now - If I make another one of these I'll probably shuffle the bottom 5-pin JST connector back 1/4 an inch. The big array of caps makes it a tight fit at the moment.
Yes, I realised that mistake. A defect to be fixed in the next revision.
 

hatmoose

Champion
Joined
Mar 25, 2021
Messages
924
Reaction score
1,941
Location
New Zealand
Hardware = done. It really is a thing of beauty - thank you!

And heavy. It feels like a serious piece of enterprise-grade piece of kit.

I'll try it with Martins stock 129x firmware and see if I can get some basic functionality and see what happens
IMG_4076 (1).jpegIMG_4075 (1).jpegIMG_4074 (1).jpeg

Speaking of enterprise-grade hardware - I'm not totally in love with the Aliexpress BNC ports.
I have an extron crosspoint that a dear friend gave me before he left the country (I hope to one day repay his kindness) and was able to establish that the footprint of the Molex BNC ports is the same as the Aliexpress ones. Will keep my eye out for "parts or repair" extron gear that I can harness for parts.
IMG_4078 (1).jpegIMG_4079 (1).jpeg
 
Top