Virtual On Oratorio Tangram/Outtrigger Joystick breakdown for reporduction/replacement

twistedsymphony

Enlightened
Staff member
Immortal
Joined
Jul 21, 2015
Messages
12,988
Reaction score
16,602
Location
NH, USA
I've been trying to source original Japanese VOOT Joysticks for YEARS (literally) I've lost about half a dozen auctions on YAJ as it seems the price on these keeps skyrocketing (the last few populated candy panels sold on YAJ for around $450, before shipping).

In all my searches I managed to snag 1 stick off of a random eBay listing. I tore it down and took photos so I figured I'd post it up here. Consider the project "idea" figuring out a reproduction or identifying who the original manufacturer is (hint: it's NOT Sanwa or Happ, I'll get to that later).

I was able to tear it apart completely except for the joint parts on the shaft, it looks like they're all just press fit but I didn't want to put too much pressure on them and risk breaking them.

voot_arcade_stick_07.jpg


more detailed photos here: http://solid-orange.com/1229

These were the sticks used in the Twin and the Candy Cabs for VOOT 5.2 through 5.66. The VO Force arcade cab sticks are supposedly the same except for the thumb button, which used a board mounted mechanical switch as opposed to a diaphragm style switch.

Dreamcast home twin sticks use the same grips but are otherwise completely different.

Someone on the Oratan forum recently posted an exploded view photo of the Sanwa Sticks that are used in the Hori Twin-Sticks for the 360 and PS3... they're nice sticks but again, a completely different design than the official arcade sticks:

BsZSJ3qCEAAASxd.jpg

The grips, while a similar ergonomic shape are quite different internally, note the differt style shaft, different locations of the bolt holes and even the wire exit and trigger hinge is different.

These There are basicaly just Sanwa JLJ-PL2-8V 8-way flight sticks with VO style grips:
file.png



Happ made the sticks for the original VO OMG Twin units but they're enormous and not even remotely similar in design to these sticks. I'm not sure who made the sticks in the Saturn, Dreamcast and PC twin sticks or the VO OMG candy sticks (which are different than the twin sticks) but it's not really worth investigating because they all suck
:P

If anyone can lend advice or information about sourcing or reproducing the original Sega VOOT arcade machine sticks or even parts I'd be highly interested.
 
Ghost bump.

I have a pair of NOS Outtrigger panels from an unused kit here, a lightly used OT panel, as well as a well used Virtual-On panel.

And all the sticks are "limp" as seen in the video below:


Have asked a few experts for advice with no clear answers. I'm going to assume this is a common issue (or I have bad luck). I've looked but can't find any info anywhere. Anyone got any idea or seen this before? Perhaps @nem ?

Also, I haven't been able to take the stick apart because of this C-Clip? I've tried all the tricks people have suggested and just making a mess of it. Is there a tool I can buy to remove these at ease? I've tried to push it out with two screwdrivers, needle nose pliers, tried force. It's just not budging.

IMG_3700.JPG
 
Last edited:
you need to disassemble the stick to see what's broken, and the first step there is removing that c-clip.

I use needle nose pliers, with the nose of the pliers pushing against each leg of the C. it takes a lot of force and you just got to be careful you don't stab your other hand with the pliers if it slips off of the c-clip (which is easy to do). if you can get it part way removed with like that, then you can get a small flat-head screw driver in there to hook into the back side of the C and pull it the rest of the way out.
 
Remarkable. Got it done first time after reading this post, even though I struggled for an hour prior using the same bloody technique.

Doesn’t look like there’s any damage or anything broken on this one. But I seem to be missing a washer you have in your picture (pasted below). I only have a washer for just under the C-Clip.

The spring isn’t broken but it doesn’t have high tension properties of say a JLF spring. Even loose fitting it back it’s easy to push in, and get stuck.

Only other noticeable difference is your spring hat is white, whereas both parts on mine are black.

IMG_1185.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Also worth mentioning when the two parts of the “hat” that holds the spring in place are together it feels sticky/tight/stuck. Have tried grease, but no real change.

You can see in the video / picture of the connected hat/spring assembly below that the spring can just get stuck in the hat. Unsure if that missing washer has anything to do with it?


MY TEARDOWN PICS:

IMG_1188.JPG
IMG_1189.JPG
IMG_1190.JPG
IMG_1191.JPG
IMG_1192.JPG
IMG_1193.JPG
 
Did a full clean and re-greased it, put it back together, but it didn’t fix the issue…

Does anyone by chance happen know the individual spare part numbers for the stick internals? I got a source but need the actual part numbers. I’m going to start with the spring…
 
There are special pliers designed to remove c clips. Quick search will show you the deal. After almost putting a screwdriver through my palm more times than I’d like to admit I got a pair and they work great. One of those tools you have that does one specific thing perfectly and is totally worth it.
 
Was there just 1 washer under your c-clip? There should be two. And I think one is a spacer of different thickness to dial in the spring tension. If you look at my pic you can see there were two washers of different thicknesses and the thickness of the 2nd washer varies from stick to stick in my experience. If your missing one that could be your issue
 
There are special pliers designed to remove c clips. Quick search will show you the deal. After almost putting a screwdriver through my palm more times than I’d like to admit I got a pair and they work great. One of those tools you have that does one specific thing perfectly and is totally worth it.
What specific pair of pliers do you have?
 
There are special pliers designed to remove c clips. Quick search will show you the deal. After almost putting a screwdriver through my palm more times than I’d like to admit I got a pair and they work great. One of those tools you have that does one specific thing perfectly and is totally worth it.
I have a couple of different pairs of circlip removal tools, but none for the style above. Keen to know what tool you found, as @Swirl also asked.

Was there just 1 washer under your c-clip? There should be two. And I think one is a spacer of different thickness to dial in the spring tension. If you look at my pic you can see there were two washers of different thicknesses and the thickness of the 2nd washer varies from stick to stick in my experience. If your missing one that could be your issue
Yep, just one washer under the clip. The thicker one as shown in your photos.

I've only taken apart one of my sticks, but I believe it's the same situation of just 1 washer on the NOS panels I have though? I could try some washers to see if it makes any difference. However, I've also heard from another user here that they too have this issue on a stick that they have, so still guessing it's maybe degredation somwhere?

Did the action of the spring in video I posted above look right?
 
No, not at all. The spring shouldn't be sticky and the stick should be considerably more stiff than a typical joystick
Tried adding a washer with no real change. It isn't as "floppy", but still not right.

Another question for you. The two pieces of the hat assembly, should they be real tight fitting? If so, that's how it is here. If not, then it takes a bit of force (as seen in the video) to seperate the two pices -- which a strong spring would have no proble doing.

At this point, I'm guessing the spring has lost it's original properties somehow?

Strange that it's happened to both new and old sticks. But all four of mine are from the same source, so perhaps it has something to do with how they were stored? Or perhaps being dormant for so long?
 
At this point, I'm guessing the spring has lost it's original properties somehow?
I think you may be right, either that or someone swapped parts out at some point.

I've made a video for you showing you what it should be like:
View: https://youtu.be/e5w1diq_cgA


also some measurements:
IMG_20261120_111349377_HDR.jpg

IMG_20261120_111331734_HDR.jpg


the spring looks to be about 22-23mm in height at rest and this unit had the 2-washer setup adding additional tension There's also no binding of the spring, it's from a diameter perspective it's practically swimming against the spring hat with lots of lateral play
 
Thank you @twistedsymphony, I know how much of a pain these are to take apart, really appreciate the help - I will do more deep diving tomorrow. Good info to go off.

While you have it disassembled; the two pieces of the hat assembly, holding the spring, when they insert into each other is it a tight fit?
 
it really shouldn't even be compressing that much... I think there is maybe 1-2mm of insertion at max compression in the stick.
looking at your pictures your spring looks like it's pre-compressed by several mm
 
Back
Top